Planetary geology · The method also says no

Hall of refuted

30 structures proposed as impact craters that the evidence ruled out. Proof that the method also says no.

Batch 4 · 30 entries · October 19, 2026 · CC BY 4.0

How to read this hall

  • Each entry shows what was proposed and what refuted it (who, when, why), with its source.
  • Refuted entries carry no %: the refutation is the data point.
  • Bedout and Shiva are not here: they appear as disputed in batch 1; reclassification is the author's call.

Status legend

  • Refuted the evidence rules it out

The 30 refuted

1. 'Meteor Strike' (Kosi Bay) Refuted

Location: South Africa (KwaZulu-Natal, western shore of Kosi Bay lagoon)

Age: not applicable

Size: 65 x 170 m depression in a dune (plus a second 50-60 m one)

Refuted

  • Proposed: rumors since the mid-1990s; 'Meteor Strike' marked on the Kosi Bay topo sheet (26°56.6′S/32°47.0′E), next to the 'Star of the Sea' mission.
  • Refuted: Brandt et al. (1999, 2001) — no impact-related deformation; magnetometry with no meteoritic material; local interviews with no memory of any impact.
  • Actual origin: wind blow-out holes in the dunes (the name arose in the 1940s-50s when the mission was renamed); 'no local mentioned a meteor crater until the white man came along'.

Primary source: Reimold & Koeberl (2014), J. Afr. Earth Sci. (PMC)

2. Aflou Refuted

Location: Algeria (12 km SSW of Aflou, Laghouat Province)

Age: Upper Tertiary (proposed)

Size: 3 x 5 km oval depression

Refuted

  • Proposed: Marks et al. (1972) — 3 x 5 km depression visible on aerial imagery; 'vitreous' samples interpreted as impact melt.
  • Refuted: Lambert et al. (1980) — no continuous rim, no strata disturbance, no shock effects; the 'vitreous' rocks were volcanic diabases younger than the structure.
  • Alternative origin: erosion at a weakened crustal spot, or karstification (limestone/gypsum dissolution).

Primary source: Reimold & Koeberl (2014), J. Afr. Earth Sci. (PMC)

3. Al Mouilah Refuted

Location: Algeria (80 km west of Laghouat)

Age: not applicable

Size: 4.5 km diameter, 130 m deep, with central dome

Refuted

  • Proposed: selected by Lambert et al. (1980) for its near-perfect circular morphology with a central dome, compared to Germany's Steinheim basin.
  • Refuted: Lambert et al. (1980) — no raised rim, no breccias or deformation; crater-wall strata undisturbed; 'no evidence for impact'.
  • Alternative origin: recent collapse from dissolution of underlying limestone/gypsum, or purely erosional processes.

Primary source: Reimold & Koeberl (2014), J. Afr. Earth Sci. (PMC)

4. Nastapoka Arc Refuted

Location: Canada (eastern Hudson Bay, Quebec)

Age: not applicable

Size: ~450 km diameter arc (155° of arc)

Refuted

  • Proposed: Beals (1968) — the near-perfect circular arc as the rim of a giant Precambrian crater (comparable to lunar Mare Crisium); Belcher Islands as central peak.
  • Refuted: Dietz and Barringer (1972) — canoe expedition along the arc: no shatter cones, no suevite, no melt rocks, no radial fractures or shock metamorphism.
  • Current consensus: arcuate tectonic boundary of the Trans-Hudson orogeny (~2.0-1.8 Ga) — continental collision, not impact (NASA Earth Observatory).

Primary source: NASA Earth Observatory — Nastapoka Arc

5. Arkenu Refuted

Location: Libya (250 km south of Al Kufrah oasis)

Age: not applicable

Size: Two structures 10.3 and 6.8 km in diameter

Refuted

  • Proposed: Paillou et al. (2003) — two circular satellite features plus field visit; claimed shatter cones and PDFs in quartz; briefly entered the Earth Impact Database.
  • Refuted: Di Martino et al. (2008) — no shock deformation; the 'cones' were wind-erosion ventifacts; Cigolini et al. (2012) — volcanic stocks (syenites) with hydrothermal activity.
  • Removed from the Earth Impact Database (also discredited by Baegi and Ben Musa, 2009).

Primary source: Reimold & Koeberl (2014), J. Afr. Earth Sci. (PMC)

6. Carolina Bays Refuted

Location: USA (Atlantic Coastal Plain, New Jersey to Florida)

Age: 12,900 years (YD proposal; actual: 140,000-2,000 years)

Size: Thousands of oriented elliptical depressions (LiDAR census: >23,000)

Refuted

  • Proposed: 1933 (revived 2007 with the Younger Dryas impact hypothesis) — the bays as secondary craters from an impact on the Laurentide ice.
  • Refuted: eolian-lacustrine modeling (Kaczorowski, 1977); GSA 2012 — no impact signatures; OSL dating: sand rims span 140,000-2,000 years, not a single event 12,900 years ago.
  • Consensus: wind-and-shallow-water oriented lakes over millennia; underlying sediments undisturbed and unshocked.

Primary source: GSA 2012 — Carolina Bay formation and evolution

7. Bir Anzarane Refuted

Location: Morocco (Saharan territory, southeast of Dakhla)

Age: not applicable

Size: ~1.5 km wide

Refuted

  • Proposed: logged by Chaabout et al. (2011) as a promising site in a GoogleEarth screening for its high circularity.
  • Refuted: June 2011 field expedition — no breccias or deformation, same strata orientation in center and rim, no shock in quartz-rich mylonites; target excluded (Chaabout et al., 2013).

Primary source: Reimold & Koeberl (2014), J. Afr. Earth Sci. (PMC)

8. Gilf Kebir crater field Refuted

Location: Egypt (Gilf Kebir plateau, Western Desert)

Age: not applicable

Size: Field of circular structures (up to 62 proposed, of ~1300 detected)

Refuted

  • Proposed: Paillou et al. (2004, 2006) — 13, then 62 possible craters on the plateau; claimed shatter cones and PDFs (later admitted possible hydrothermal origin).
  • Refuted: Italian expedition Orti et al. (2008) — no genuine shock deformation; 'cones' = wind erosion; sedimentary/tectonic breccias; no bowl-shaped geophysical geometry.
  • Conclusion: endogenous volcanic/geothermal processes after sedimentary cover deposition.

Primary source: Reimold & Koeberl (2014), J. Afr. Earth Sci. (PMC)

9. Chegutu Refuted

Location: Zimbabwe (Chegutu station, 18°08′S/30°08′E)

Age: not applicable

Size: Geophysical anomaly (no defined surface structure)

Refuted

  • Proposed: Zimbabwe's strongest negative aeromagnetic anomaly (−800 gamma rim-to-center) + breccias hoped to be impact-related (Reimold, 1994).
  • Refuted: the breccias turned out to be volcanic agglomerates; the anomaly's origin remains unsolved, but it is not impact.

Primary source: Reimold & Koeberl (2014), J. Afr. Earth Sci. (PMC)

10. Chiemgau (Tüttensee) Refuted

Location: Germany (Bavaria, Lake Tüttensee)

Age: 1st millennium BC (proposed)

Size: Field of depressions (Tüttensee as the main crater)

Refuted

  • Proposed: Chiemgau Impact Research Team (Rappenglück et al.) — Bavarian crater field from a 1st-millennium-BC impact, linked to the Phaethon myth.
  • Refuted: Doppler et al. (2011, Antiquity, peer-reviewed) — radiocarbon-dated drilling: undisturbed sequence from 4,800 to 12,500 years; the basin formed at the end of the Ice Age.
  • Actual origin: a dead-ice hole, as German geologists have known for a century.

Primary source: ScienceBlogs (Aardvarchaeology) — sobre Doppler et al. 2011

11. Bushveld Complex Refuted

Location: South Africa (northern part of the country)

Age: 2054-2061 Ma (age of the intrusion; proposed as impact)

Size: 500 x 350 km (world's largest layered igneous intrusion)

Refuted

  • Proposed: Hamilton (1970), Rhodes (1975), Elston (1995, 2008) — multiple-impact origin; the Rooiberg sequence as impact melt; shock in quartz claimed by Labuschagne (1970).
  • Refuted: French (1990) found no shock metamorphism; Joreau et al. (1996, electron microscopy) — the features were low-strain tectonic deformation, not PDFs; confirmed by Buchanan and Reimold (1998).
  • Consensus: endogenous igneous intrusion (famous for its platinum, chromium and vanadium resources).

Primary source: Reimold & Koeberl (2014), J. Afr. Earth Sci. (PMC)

12. Hicks Dome Refuted

Location: USA (Illinois, Hardin County)

Age: ~330-310 Ma (proposed)

Size: ~13-16 km diameter (8 miles)

Refuted

  • Proposed: Rampino and Volk (1996) — one of eight aligned '38th parallel' craters (Paleozoic impact chain); 'shocked' quartz claimed (Weller and Grogan, 1945).
  • Refuted: geological consensus — large-scale igneous intrusion and deep brecciation (Bradbury and Baxter, 1992); dome lacking the ring depression and raised rim of a complex crater; no shock indicators.
  • The dome sits at the center of the Illinois-Kentucky fluorspar district; the lava 'almost' erupted as a volcano (Illinois State Geological Survey).

Primary source: Illinois State Geological Survey — Impact Structures in the US

13. El Baz Refuted

Location: Egypt (Great Sand Sea, Western Desert)

Age: not applicable

Size: 4 km diameter

Refuted

  • Proposed: El-Baz (1981) — circular Landsat feature compared to Meteor Crater (Arizona); later linked to cryptoexplosive activity (El-Baz and Issawi, 1982).
  • Refuted: Orti et al. (2008) — feature bounded by basalt dikes intruded into quartz arenite; volcanic activity in the area; no evidence of impact.
  • Listed among discredited impact proposals (Reimold and Koeberl, 2014).

Primary source: Reimold & Koeberl (2014), J. Afr. Earth Sci. (PMC)

14. Habhab Refuted

Location: Oman

Age: not applicable

Size: Two dark concentric rings, 6 and 2 km

Refuted

  • Proposed: two-concentric-ring structure (Grieve et al., 1988; McHone and Dietz, 1988).
  • Refuted: Hofmann et al. (2003) — detailed field study with no evidence for an impact origin.
  • Alternative origin: salt dissolution / salt tectonics related to a near-surface salt plug.

Primary source: Chabou — estructuras de impacto desacreditadas en el mundo arabe

15. Kebira Refuted

Location: Libya/Egypt (border, Gilf Kebir region)

Age: not applicable

Size: 31 km diameter (proposed)

Refuted

  • Proposed: El-Baz and Ghoneim (2007) — 'the largest crater in the Sahara' (31 km) from Landsat/Radarsat alone; suggested as the Libyan desert glass source, with no fieldwork.
  • Refuted: later field visits found no evidence; the supposed 'central uplift' retains the horizontal bedding of the sandstone; not listed in the Earth Impact Database.
  • Reimold and Koeberl (2014): 'no tangible evidence on the table; the claim is unfounded and unsubstantiated'.

Primary source: Reimold & Koeberl (2014), J. Afr. Earth Sci. (PMC)

16. Köfels Refuted

Location: Austria (Ötztal, Tyrol)

Age: ~9,000 years (of the landslide; impact proposal: Holocene)

Size: Giant landslide (impact proposed with no defined crater)

Refuted

  • Proposed: (1936) — the 'pumice' (frictionite) and crushed rocks as ejecta of a Holocene meteorite impact (natural glass was only known from volcanoes or impacts).
  • Refuted: Erismann et al. (1977) — frictional melting from the giant landslide (~9,000 years); quartz shows no shock defects: the glass formed by slow high-temperature melting, not shock.
  • The reported 'shocked quartz' proved tectonic on re-examination; crater, ejecta and shocked quartz of a ~1 km impactor are missing.

Primary source: History of Geology — The landslide of Köfels

17. Nedlukseak circular lake Refuted

Location: Canada (Nunavut, Baffin Island, Nedlukseak Fiord; Auyuittuq NP)

Age: not applicable

Size: Small circular lake (possible >15 m meteorite crater)

Refuted

  • Proposed: circular lake on a headland between two branches of Nedlukseak Fiord as a possible crater from a meteorite larger than 15 metres.
  • Refuted: summer 2018 expedition (Asimow, Caltech; Horton, WHOI; Biasi) — ordinary glacial lake: no raised rim, no radial fractures, no shatter cones; samples negative for shock and geochemistry.
  • Parks Canada: 'approximately circular features can arise by coincidence or by the ordinary action of glaciers and erosion'.

Primary source: Parks Canada — Discovery of an impact crater in Arctic Canada

18. Lac Télé Refuted

Location: Republic of Congo (between Epena and the Likouala River)

Age: Holocene (alluvium)

Size: 6 x 8 km oval lake, 4 m mean depth

Refuted

  • Proposed: Garvin (1986) — conspicuously oval lake from remote sensing, with radial drainage; options: eroded impact, collapsed caldera or subsidence.
  • Refuted: Master (2010b) — morphology inconsistent with a complex crater (no deep basin, no overturned rim, no ejecta); shallow flat-bottomed lake over neotectonic lineaments.
  • Alternative origin: drainage damming by reactivated neotectonic faults (several similar lakes exist in the Congo Basin).

Primary source: Reimold & Koeberl (2014), J. Afr. Earth Sci. (PMC)

19. Lakes Isli and Tislit Refuted

Location: Morocco (High Atlas, near Imilchil)

Age: not applicable

Size: Two circular lakes (alleged 'double crater')

Refuted

  • Proposed: Ibhi et al. (2013) — two craters from circularity, proximity to the Agoudal meteorite and claimed PDFs; Moroccan press reported a 'double crater' in 2012.
  • Refuted: Chaabout et al. (2013) expedition with Reimold — no quartz suitable for shock search, no shock deformation or cones; limestone, marl and mudstone; no cataclysmic deformation.
  • Accepted origin: lakes in a tectonic synclinal basin (Michard et al., 2011); 'to date no unambiguous evidence for impact structures at Isli and Tislit'.

Primary source: Reimold & Koeberl (2014), J. Afr. Earth Sci. (PMC)

20. Mazoula Refuted

Location: Algeria (28°24′N/7°49′E)

Age: Cretaceous (of the actual structure: reef)

Size: 800 m diameter, 300 m wide anticlinal dome

Refuted

  • Proposed: 800 m multi-ring feature with a 30-35 m anticlinal dome; investigated by Lambert et al. (1981).
  • Refuted: Lambert et al. (1981) — no rock disturbance, no fractures, no breccias; not of impact origin.
  • Actual origin: Cretaceous rudist reef and/or salt diapir.

Primary source: Reimold & Koeberl (2014), J. Afr. Earth Sci. (PMC)

21. Nyika Plateau Refuted

Location: Malawi (Nyika National Park, Chilinda pine plantation)

Age: 1959 (alleged; the real event was in 1960)

Size: Alleged 80 m crater

Refuted

  • Proposed: Mossman (1972) — hearsay of a 1959 impact forming an 80 m crater (bright light, loud explosion).
  • Refuted: Master and Duane (1998) — the site coincides with the Chilinda mudslide of 23 April 1960 from waterlogged clayey soils; plantation workers' testimony confirms it.
  • Conclusion: no possibility that a meteorite strike occurred.

Primary source: Reimold & Koeberl (2014), J. Afr. Earth Sci. (PMC)

22. Michelifene Refuted

Location: Morocco (33°24′N/5°04′W)

Age: not applicable

Size: ~1 km diameter

Refuted

  • Proposed: circular structure studied by Martin (1981) and Gigout (1955).
  • Refuted: long known as a volcanic explosion crater; the breccia is from volcanic eruptive activity — no evidence of impact origin.

Primary source: Reimold & Koeberl (2014), J. Afr. Earth Sci. (PMC)

23. Lukanga Swamp Refuted

Location: Zambia (100 km west of Kabwe)

Age: not applicable

Size: 52 km diameter (proposed)

Refuted

  • Proposed: Vrána (1985) — 52 km structure from breccias and an aeromagnetic anomaly; claimed shock PDFs in breccia quartz.
  • Refuted: Katongo et al. (2002) — 96 field samples: no shock deformation (features were misidentified tectonic fluid inclusions); no meteoritic geochemical or magnetic impact signature.
  • Alternative origin: reactivation of the Nyama and Kapiri-Mposhi dislocation zones, possibly in the Cenozoic.

Primary source: Reimold & Koeberl (2014), J. Afr. Earth Sci. (PMC)

24. Richat Refuted

Location: Mauritania (Adrar, 21°04′N/11°22′W; 'Eye of the Sahara')

Age: ~98 Ma (dome emplacement; not impact)

Size: ~40-50 km diameter (44 km measured on satellite)

Refuted

  • Proposed: Cailleux et al. (1964), Freeburg (1966) — the circular 'eye' as an impact crater; claimed coesite in brecciated quartzite.
  • Refuted: Dietz et al. (1969) — no shatter cones, no megabreccia, no microscopic shock; Fudali (1969) — the 'coesite' was misidentified barite.
  • Matton et al. (2005, Geology): eroded dome with basaltic ring dikes and Cretaceous alkaline intrusions (~98.2 Ma); 'no evidence remains that could be linked to an impact origin'.

Primary source: Reimold & Koeberl (2014), J. Afr. Earth Sci. (PMC)

25. Save East and West Refuted

Location: Zimbabwe (near the Mozambican border)

Age: Karoo (volcanism; not impact)

Size: 600 and 800 m wide (twin structures)

Refuted

  • Proposed: twin crater-like features (the smaller with a pronounced crater shape), Tswaing-like on satellite; previously referred to as volcanic pipes/kimberlites.
  • Refuted: Reimold (1994); Master and Robertson (2009) — ground magnetics suggest vertical cylindrical volcanic bodies hundreds of meters deep; Karoo Supergroup-time volcanism.

Primary source: Reimold & Koeberl (2014), J. Afr. Earth Sci. (PMC)

26. Semsiyat Refuted

Location: Mauritania (Chinguetti Plateau, 50 km WSW of Richat)

Age: not applicable

Size: ~5 km diameter

Refuted

  • Proposed: Dietz et al. (1969) referred to it as a second dome ('petit frère' of Richat), with rings visible on satellite imagery.
  • Refuted: Dietz et al. (1969) — no shatter cones or evidence of exogenic action; by similarity with Richat, endogenous origin.

Primary source: Reimold & Koeberl (2014), J. Afr. Earth Sci. (PMC)

27. Shakiso Refuted

Location: Ethiopia (south-central, Adola gold field)

Age: 10-65 Ma (proposed, no analytical data)

Size: 2.5-6 km diameter (proposed)

Refuted

  • Proposed: Evdokimov (1987), Evdokimov and Abebe (1987) — 'impactites and explosion breccias', Ni-Fe pellets and 'shatter cones' over Shakiso town.
  • Refuted: Abate and Koeberl (1998) — detailed fieldwork, petrography and geochemistry with no evidence of an impact structure.

Primary source: Reimold & Koeberl (2014), J. Afr. Earth Sci. (PMC)

28. Delmas sinkhole Refuted

Location: South Africa (10 km east of Delmas, Mpumalanga)

Age: not applicable

Size: ~140 m diameter (~70 m radius), 50+ m deep

Refuted

  • Proposed: 'Meteorite Hole' marked on the official 1:50,000 topo-cadastral map (sheet 2628BB Kendal); concentric structure ~70 m in radius; flagged by Reinie Meyer in 2011.
  • Refuted: April 2012 field inspection — old karst sinkhole in dolomite (Malmani Subgroup) with intact horizontal layering; area prone to sinkholes from groundwater overexploitation.

Primary source: Reimold & Koeberl (2014), J. Afr. Earth Sci. (PMC)

29. Thuli Refuted

Location: Zimbabwe (100 km west of Beitbridge)

Age: not applicable

Size: 1100 m diameter

Refuted

  • Proposed: circular structure on aerial photos and the 1:100,000 Thuli geological map; panorama similar to South Africa's Tswaing impact crater.
  • Refuted: Reimold (1994) — volcanic origin from abundant basalt, gabbro and diorite; crater-like form from differential weathering of those igneous products.

Primary source: Reimold & Koeberl (2014), J. Afr. Earth Sci. (PMC)

30. Tor Refuted

Location: Sweden (Härjedalen, Torbygget)

Age: ~2,000 years (proposed)

Size: Small semi-circular depression

Refuted

  • Proposed: earlier investigations — the Torbygget depression as a meteorite impact crater from ~2,000 years ago.
  • Refuted: Öhrling et al. (2021, GFF) — a grounded-iceberg scour mark on the bed of an ice-dammed lake during deglaciation (~11,000-10,000 cal. BP).
  • Plado et al. (2022, MAPS): topography, geophysics, 10Be and 14C dating — no method supports an impact origin.

Primary source: Plado et al. (2022), MAPS — Tor crater (resumen)

Honest limits

Verification level: web index. 22 entries come from Reimold & Koeberl (2014) on disproven African structures; the rest verified case by case. The EDEIS V=0 list was unreachable.

Pending: 4 cases set aside (Sirente, Lloydminster, Silverpit, Azuara/Rubielos) over active dispute or lack of a citable source.