The First Signs of Life

The first seeds of life we can date — seven lineages with a date, a face and descendants.

An outreach piece from Mathvsmyth.com. The first living beings that science can date: seven real lineages of Earth, each with its date, its face — what it looks like —, its requirements to progress and its descendants. They are not invention: they are real life, with its real numbers, just as the scientific record supports it.

WHAT IS A SIGN? — How to date a life without bones

Of the beings in this piece almost never does the body remain: three kinds of trace remain, and each card says which one its date comes from.

  • · THE BODY — the remain itself. It is the most direct sign and the latest one: of the ancient lineages there are almost no bodies; the clear ones in this piece are the lichen (~400 Ma) and the tardigrade (~500 Ma).
  • · THE WORK — what the being built. Cyanobacteria raise mounds layer by layer, the stromatolites: the oldest solid ones are ~3,480 Ma old (Dresser Formation, Australia) [DATA]; there are claims of ~3,700 Ma in Greenland [IN DISPUTE].
  • · THE CHEMICAL TRACE — isotopes and molecules with a signature of life: light carbon in the rocks of Isua, ~3,800 Ma [IN DISPUTE]; and the banded iron of the oceans, the indirect trace that something was already producing oxygen.

The rule that governs them all

No known life divides below a water activity of

aw ≈ 0.605

The limit is set by the xerophilic fungus Xeromyces bisporus and some halophilic archaea (Stevenson et al., 2015). Translated into practice: without available water — liquid, or in hygroscopic salts above that threshold — no kit grows. At most, it waits dormant.

«Survival is not colonization.»
«Producing is not instantaneous: oxygenating a world takes eras, not years.»

Source: Stevenson et al. 2015.

The tree of the seeds

Family tree of the seven seeds: a single trunk that is time, from which the lineages of Bacteria, Archaea and Eukarya branch out; each seed is in its colour and all the lines reach today
A single trunk: time. Each colour is a lineage and all the lines reach today — the seven lineages live. The scale is declared in the image itself: the stretch from 4,000 to 1,000 Ma is compressed and the recent one, expanded. The tardigrade is the straightest line: 500 million years almost without changes. Original figure by JCEA Labs · CC BY 4.0.

The edge of the known: LUCA

LUCA has never been observed. It is not a fossil: it is an inference — the never-proven datum that holds up the whole tree. We include it and represent it just as science classifies it: theoretical to this day.

What we can verify Data

Everything alive shares almost the same genetic code, the same base amino acids, the same energy currency (ATP) and the same machinery (ribosomes, DNA→RNA→protein). That universal coincidence can only be explained if everything descends from a single common ancestor: LUCA (Last Universal Common Ancestor).

By comparing genomes, traits are reconstructed for it: it was a cell with a DNA genome; the study by Weiss et al. 2016 (Nature Microbiology) traced ~355 gene families back to it and depicts it as anaerobic, dependent on H2, fixing CO2 via the Wood-Ljungdahl pathway.

What is still under investigation In dispute Theory

Its date: molecular clock estimates place it at around ~4,200 Ma (range 4,090–4,330 Ma) — Moody et al. 2024, Nature Ecology & Evolution — already surprisingly complex, with a genome of at least 2.5 Mb and even an early immune system; the exact date is debated.

Its home: the favourite theory is the hydrothermal vents Theory.

The finest question: whether it was one being or a population that exchanged genes — with horizontal transfer, «LUCA» may have been a community, not an individual In dispute.

Its face: unknown; any drawing of LUCA is imagination and must say so.

In our tree, LUCA is placed in fog on purpose: the fog is not a decoration, it is the exact form of what we know — the order of the branches, yes; the face, no.

This card remains open. Perhaps in ten years someone will find it, refute it or a new name will arise for it: that day, this page will be corrected with a date and with the name of whoever brought it. What can be proven, and what is still under investigation: that is MathvsMyth.

Seed 1 of 7

Cyanobacteria

«The oxygen factory»

What it looks like Light microscope micrograph of a filament of Anabaena sphaerica: a chain of green cells with a heterocyst, the larger, rounded cell, in the centre
Light microscope micrograph of a filament of Anabaena sphaerica: the chain of green cells, and in the centre the larger, rounded cell — a heterocyst, the cell that fixes nitrogen. Credit: Elapied (reworked image, uploaded to the French Wikipedia; derived from File:Image-Anabaena sperica.jpeg), via Wikimedia Commons. License: CC BY-SA 3.0. · 2009

The seed

Photosynthetic bacteria: Synechococcus, Nostoc and Anabaena, the latter filamentous, forming mats and stromatolites.

What it does for a world

It is the only kit that truly oxygenates: oxygenic photosynthesis (light + H2O + CO2 → biomass + O2). It also fixes carbon, and several species fix nitrogen in special cells called heterocysts. It is the kit that transformed Earth: its precedent is the Great Oxidation.

Requirements to progress

TemperatureMost work in a temperate mesophilic range; the absolute ceiling of photosynthesis on Earth is ~73 °C, reached only by thermophilic Synechococcus in alkaline springs. In acidic environments the phototrophic ceiling drops to ~56 °C, and there they are already eukaryotic red algae, not cyanobacteria.
WaterLiquid, mandatory — and above aw ≈ 0.605.
Light / O₂Visible light mandatory: without light, production is zero. It produces O2, it does not need it.
pHBroad in freshwater and marine genera; the record thermophiles live in alkaline waters.
The honest trap: the timescale. Between when cyanobacteria began producing O2 (~2,900 Ma) and when oxygen accumulated in the atmosphere (Great Oxidation, ~2,400 Ma) hundreds of millions of years passed, because the O2 was first devoured by sinks — the iron dissolved in the oceans, which left the banded iron formations. The phase of sustained accumulation lasted 200–300 million years. Before oxygenating, the world's reducing sinks must be exhausted. And note: the O2 of this kit is poison for the anaerobic kits (Kit 5).

Its first evolution

Its destiny on Earth

Its descendants on Earth, in two steps:

The chain: first → second

First evolution

Cells with a trade (~2,000 Ma, with caution): they invent heterocysts, cells dedicated solely to fixing nitrogen — the first "organ" of a bacterium.

No new photo: this step is already in the card — in the photograph of Anabaena in «What it looks like», above, the heterocyst can be seen, the larger, rounded cell of the filament.

Second evolution

Being captured (~1,500 Ma) [IN DISPUTE]: a cyanobacterium ends up living inside another cell and becomes the chloroplast; from there algae and plants arise.

Transmission electron micrograph of Chlamydomonas reinhardtii: the nucleus and the large chloroplast inside the cell can be distinguished
Transmission electron micrograph of Chlamydomonas reinhardtii, a unicellular green alga: the nucleus and the large chloroplast that occupies a good part of the cell can be distinguished — the descendant of that captured cyanobacterium. Credit: Dartmouth Electron Microscope Facility, Dartmouth College, via Wikimedia Commons. License: public domain. · 2007

A datum the chain does not repeat: from when they produce O2 (~2,900 Ma) to the chloroplast, ~1,400 million years passed.

On Earth: when did it live, is it still alive?

They have been producing oxygen for ~2,900 million years (MIT estimate) and caused the Great Oxidation ~2,400 Ma. They are still alive today: they are in oceans, lakes, soils and hot springs all over the planet.

Source: ASM (Great Oxidation) and Applied and Environmental Microbiology (ceiling of photosynthesis, 73 °C).

Seed 2 of 7

Nitrogen fixers

«The living fertilizer»

What it looks like Photograph of soybean roots covered with small nodules where the rhizobia live
Photograph of soybean roots covered with nodules: inside each nodule live billions of rhizobia fixing nitrogen. Credit: U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA), via Wikimedia Commons. Public domain (work of the U.S. government). · 2005

The seed

Azotobacter (free-living, aerobic), Anabaena and Nostoc (cyanobacteria with heterocysts) and the rhizobia, symbionts of legumes.

What it does for a world

It converts atmospheric N2, inert, into assimilable ammonia. Without this there are no proteins, no fertile soil, no complex ecosystem. It produces biologically active soil.

Requirements to progress

TemperatureFixation in soils: thermal optimum 25–35 °C. Azotobacter: optimum 25–30 °C; its vegetative cells die at 45–48 °C.
WaterNecessary, above aw ≈ 0.605, as in the whole catalogue.
Light / O₂The enzyme nitrogenase is destroyed by free O2: each fixer protects it in its own way — Azotobacter breathes so fast that it burns O2 at its surface; Anabaena confines fixation to heterocysts without oxygen. It also needs gaseous N2, organic carbon as fuel and molybdenum/iron for the enzyme.
pHIn soils, the preferred is 6–7. Azotobacter grows at pH ~4.5–8.5, with an optimum neutral to slightly alkaline (7.2–8.2).
The honest trap: rhizobia need a host legume plant — without plants in the world, this sub-kit does not work on its own; it is a structural limit, not one of parameters. And fixing nitrogen costs a great deal of energy (16 ATP per each N2): free-living fixers contribute little and slowly if carbon is lacking. Moreover, this kit processes nitrogen, it does not create it: without N2 in the atmosphere there is nothing to fix.

Its first evolution

Its destiny on Earth

Its descendants on Earth, in two steps:

The chain: first → second

First evolution

Entering plants through the old door: the fixing cyanobacteria settle in the coralloid roots of cycads — a very ancient symbiosis, hundreds of millions of years old.

Photograph of the coralloid roots of Cycas circinalis, shaped like coral, on the ground
Photograph of the coralloid roots of Cycas circinalis — roots shaped like coral inside which the nitrogen-fixing cyanobacteria live. Credit: PeregrinusX, via Wikimedia Commons. License: CC BY-SA 3.0. · 2007
Second evolution

The modern nodule (~55–60 Ma) [DATA]: rhizobia enter the roots of legumes by recycling the signalling of mycorrhizae.

No new photo: this step is the photograph in «What it looks like» of this card — the soybean roots covered with nodules.

A datum the chain does not repeat: the recycled signalling was that of mycorrhizae, from ~450 Ma. And there is a third one under way, today: science is trying to transfer fixation to cereals.

On Earth: when did it live, is it still alive?

The fixation of N2 has isotopic evidence from ~3,200 million years ago — it is older than the Great Oxidation itself. The lineage is still alive today, in soils and roots all over the planet.

Source: Bergey's Manual and biogeochemistry notes (Fiveable).

Seed 3 of 7

Extremophiles of volcanoes and fumaroles

Those that live where a world is still hell

What it looks like Electron micrograph of a lobed cell of Pyrolobus fumarii, with a scale bar of 1 micrometre
Electron micrograph of a cell of Pyrolobus fumarii, the hyperthermophilic archaeon of the underwater black smokers — the organism, not its habitat (scale bar: 1 µm). Credit: Manfred Rohde, via Wikimedia Commons. License: CC BY-SA 4.0. · image from 1999

The seed

Two extreme archaea: Pyrolobus fumarii, hyperthermophile of the underwater black smokers, and Picrophilus oshimae, thermoacidophile of the solfataras.

What it does for a world

It colonizes the niches that no other kit touches — volcanoes, hot springs, vents — and begins chemosynthetic primary production, without light, as well as the weathering of volcanic rock.

Requirements to progress

TemperaturePyrolobus: grows between 90 and 113 °C (optimum 106 °C); below 90 °C it stops growing, and it survives 1 hour at 121 °C in an autoclave. Picrophilus: 47–65 °C (optimum 60 °C).
WaterNecessary, above aw ≈ 0.605. Pyrolobus even grew at 250 bar of pressure.
Light / O₂Pyrolobus is an obligate chemolithoautotroph: it lives on H2 + CO2, it uses neither light nor organic matter. Picrophilus, in contrast, is an obligate aerobic heterotroph: it needs oxygen and organic food.
pHPyrolobus: pH 4.0–6.5 (optimum 5.5). Picrophilus: pH ~0 to 3.5 (optimum 0.7 — the most extreme acidophile known).
The honest trap: they are specialists with a trap. Picrophilus breaks down and dies above pH 4 — its membrane becomes permeable — and since it needs O2 and prior biomass, it cannot be a first colonizer of a world. And Pyrolobus completely ignores the temperate surface: for it, 60 °C is lethal freezing. Note: the 113 °C of Pyrolobus in its day set the temperature ceiling of known life; there is a later report of growth at 121 °C (the «strain 121»), not yet fully characterized with caution.

Its first evolution

Its destiny on Earth

Its descendants on Earth, in two steps:

The chain: first → second

First evolution

In Pyrolobus, none: stasis in the fumaroles — its "evolution" was to stay.

No new photo: this step is the micrograph of Pyrolobus fumarii in «What it looks like», above in this same card.

Second evolution

That of its family (~2,000 Ma) [IN DISPUTE]: a related archaeon hosted a bacterium and from there the eukaryotic cell was born. The step was not taken by Pyrolobus: it was taken by its lineage.

Image to be requested — donation to knowledge

A datum the chain does not repeat: the host archaeon was of the Asgard type, and from that event every animal and every plant descends.

On Earth: when did it live, is it still alive?

Both species were isolated from present-day volcanic environments — underwater fumaroles and solfataras — and they are still alive today in those niches. Their lineage, that of the archaea, is among the oldest on the planet and was the protagonist of the eukaryogenesis of ~2,000 Ma ago.

Source: Blöchl et al. 1997 (Pyrolobus) and Fütterer et al. 2004, PNAS (Picrophilus).

Seed 4 of 7

Deinococcus radiodurans

«The anti-radiation insurance»

What it looks like Transmission electron micrograph of Deinococcus radiodurans grouped in a tetrad
Transmission electron micrograph (TEM) of Deinococcus radiodurans grouped in a tetrad, its typical form in fours. Credit: TEM obtained in the laboratory of Michael Daly, Uniformed Services University, Bethesda, MD, USA (via Oak Ridge National Laboratory), Wikimedia Commons. Public domain (work of the U.S. government). · 2003

The seed

A Gram-positive bacterium, pigmented red and aerobic — famous for reconstructing its own genome made into pieces.

What it does for a world

It neither oxygenates nor fertilizes: it survives where the other kits die — surfaces without a magnetosphere, high-radiation zones, radioactive debris. It also reduces metals and radionuclides (U(VI), Tc(VII), Cr(VI)) to less soluble forms: it is the bioremediation kit.

Requirements to progress

TemperatureMesophilic: usual growth temperature in the laboratory ~30 °C not verified.
WaterTo grow, the usual one: above aw ≈ 0.605. Dry, in contrast, it resists extreme desiccation and prolonged vacuum.
Light / O₂It is aerobic: it needs oxygen and nutrients.
RadiationIt tolerates 5,000 Gy of acute ionizing radiation without appreciable loss of viability, and 15,000 Gy with ~37 % survival. It grows continuously under chronic radiation of 60 Gy/h. In scale: 5 Gy kill a human; 200–800 Gy kill E. coli.
The honest trap: it is a survivor, not a builder. Its contribution to the ecosystem is marginal: it serves to maintain gene banks and remediate irradiated zones, not to terraform by itself.

Its first evolution

Its destiny on Earth

Its descendants on Earth:

The chain: first → second

First and second: they are not known. Its only documented chapter is the origin of its shield, which was born against soil desiccation, not against radiation. Afterwards: perfected stasis.

On Earth: when did it live, is it still alive?

Its date of origin is not established — it is the only kit in the catalogue without a date, and so it is stated. It is still alive today, isolated from environments as common as soils and as extreme as radioactive facilities.

Source: Murray 1992 in The Prokaryotes and PNAS (proteome).

Seed 5 of 7

Methanogens

«The methane boiler»

What it looks like Micrograph of packets of cells of Methanosarcina barkeri strain Fusaro
Micrograph of Methanosarcina barkeri strain Fusaro: the packets of cells (sarcinae) of the archaeon that produces methane. Credit: U.S. Department of Energy / Joint Genome Institute (genome.jgi.doe.gov), via Wikimedia Commons. Public domain. · 2008

The seed

Methane-producing archaea: Methanosarcina, Methanopyrus kandleri and Methanocaldococcus jannaschii.

What it does for a world

It converts H2 + CO2 (or acetate) into CH4: a greenhouse gas much more potent than CO2. It is the biological tool to warm a cold, anoxic world — primitive Mars is the model scenario — and, incidentally, a storable fuel.

Requirements to progress

TemperatureThe group as a whole covers from −2 °C to 122 °C depending on the species. Methanosarcina in bioreactors: 35–55 °C. The hyperthermophiles: M. kandleri, optimum 98 °C; M. jannaschii, optimum 85 °C.
WaterThey need an aqueous medium (≥50 % water in technical systems) and a very low redox potential (< −330 mV).
Light / O₂Zero oxygen: they are strict anaerobes and free O2 inhibits methanogenesis. They do not need light.
pHThe group covers pH 3.0–10.2 depending on the species, but with culture honesty: most cultured species grow best at pH 6–8, and none cultured grows below pH 5.6. Methanosarcina: pH 6.5–7.5.
The honest trap: they are the mirror of Kit 1. When a world becomes oxygenated, this kit becomes extinct at the surface and only survives sheltered in anoxic sediments. Warming with methane and oxygenating are paths that exclude each other on the same surface. (Verified datum of Martian relevance: there is specific experimental literature on methanogens under perchlorates — the salts of the soil of Mars — as candidates for subsurface niches.)

Its first evolution

Its destiny on Earth

Its descendants on Earth, in two steps:

The chain: first → second

First evolution

Losing the world (~2,400 Ma): the Great Oxidation expels them to airless refuges; their evolution was one of retreat and specialization in sediments.

Photograph of an outcrop of black shale, marine sediment deposited without oxygen
Photograph of marine sediment deposited without oxygen, today black shale (New Albany Shale, Devonian; MacDonald Knob, Bullitt County, Kentucky, USA) — the type of anoxic bottom to which the methanogens retreated and where their present-day equivalents still live. Credit: James St. John, via Wikimedia Commons. License: CC BY 2.0. · photo from 2018
Second evolution

One branch surrendered to oxygen: descendants of theirs lost methanogenesis and became the aerobic halophiles of the brines.

Photograph from the International Space Station of the salt ponds of the south of San Francisco Bay, with green, red and pink lagoons
Photograph taken from the International Space Station of the salt ponds of the south of San Francisco Bay; the red and pink of the most concentrated lagoons are produced by halophilic microbes — among them the haloarchaea, the aerobic descendants of the methanogens. Credit: NASA astronaut photograph (STS111-376-3), via Wikimedia Commons. License: public domain. · photo from 2002

On Earth: when did it live, is it still alive?

They date from primitive, anoxic Earth, and were expelled to the refuges since the Great Oxidation, ~2,400 million years ago. They are still alive today: in sediments, swamps, the ocean floor and the intestine of animals — in every place without oxygen.

Source: review of methanogenesis (Energies/MDPI) and García et al. 2000.

Seed 6 of 7

Lichens and pioneer fungi

«Those that eat rock»

What it looks like Photograph of Xanthoria elegans, an orange lichen of circular shape growing on rock
Photograph of Xanthoria elegans, the orange lichen, growing on rock (scale bar: 1 cm). Credit: Jason Hollinger (original photograph; image no. 97571 of Mushroom Observer), with derived editing by Papa Lima Whiskey, via Wikimedia Commons. License: CC BY-SA 3.0. · photo from 2009

The seed

The lichens Rhizocarpon geographicum and Xanthoria elegans — each one, a symbiosis of fungus + photobiont — and the Antarctic endolithic fungi, which live inside the rock.

What it does for a world

It is the first colonizer of bare rock: it weathers the mineral, retains moisture, begins soil formation and provides a modest photosynthesis. It is the bridge kit between «rock» and «soil».

Requirements to progress

TemperatureActive in a temperate–cold range, with moisture. Dormant, it withstands extreme thermal oscillations.
WaterEpisodic: they are poikilohydric — they switch on with moisture and switch off when dry.
Light / O₂Light: the photobiont photosynthesizes. And a rock to hold on to.
EvidenceThis is not theory, it is experiment: in BIOPAN/Foton-M2 (ESA, 2005), both species spent 14.6 days in open space — vacuum, full solar UV, cosmic radiation — and returned with total survival and intact photosynthetic capacity. In EXPOSE-E (ISS, 2008–2009), X. elegans endured 18 months outside the station: mean viability of the photobiont 71 % and of the mycobiont 84 %; in the compartment with a Mars-analogue atmosphere, viability was even somewhat higher. The endolithic fungal communities preserved >60 % of intact cells after 18 months in simulated Martian conditions.
The honest trap: in space they did not grow — they slept (anhydrobiosis). And their pace is geological on a human scale: the growth of crustose lichens is measured in millimetres per year not verified. Perfect for surviving the journey and waking up on arrival; useless if there is a hurry.

Its first evolution

Its destiny on Earth

Its descendants on Earth, in two steps:

The chain: first → second

First evolution

Preparing the soil: they already are an evolution (the symbiosis); their next step was ecological — eating rock and making the soil where land plants could enter (~470 Ma).

Photograph of the fossil of Rhynia: cross-section of a stem preserved in the Rhynie chert
Photograph of the fossil of Rhynia — cross-section of a stem —, one of the first land plants, preserved in the Rhynie chert (Scotland) — the plant world that entered on the soil that the rock-eating pioneers had prepared. Credit: Peter Coxhead, via Wikimedia Commons. License: CC BY-SA 4.0. · photo from 2019
Second evolution

They were three, not two (2016) [DATA]: many lichens carry a third partner, a yeast hidden in the cortex, invisible during 150 years of microscopes.

Photograph of a lichen of the genus Bryoria hanging from a branch
Photograph of a lichen of the genus Bryoria — the genus in which in 2016 the hidden third partner was discovered. Credit: Przykuta, via Wikimedia Commons. License: CC BY-SA 3.0. · photo from 2010

A datum the chain does not repeat: the fungus + photobiont symbiosis was invented several times separately.

On Earth: when did it live, is it still alive?

The oldest unequivocal lichen fossil is Winfrenatia reticulata, from Rhynie, Scotland: ~400 million years. There are claims of ~600 Ma (Doushantuo) under debate. They are still alive today, from Antarctica to the deserts, on bare rock.

Source: ESA/BIOPAN and Brandt et al. 2015 (EXPOSE-E).

Seed 7 of 7

Tardigrades

«The fauna that waits»

What it looks like Scanning electron micrograph of Milnesium tardigradum in active state, walking on its eight legs
Scanning electron micrograph (SEM) of Milnesium tardigradum in active state. Credit: Schokraie E, Warnken U, Hotz-Wagenblatt A, Grohme MA, Hengherr S, et al. (2012), PLoS ONE 7(9): e45682. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0045682, via Wikimedia Commons. License: CC BY 2.5. · 2012

The seed

Microanimals of ~0.5 mm: Milnesium tardigradum, Richtersius coronifer and relatives — the «water bears».

What it does for a world

Strictly, nothing: it does not oxygenate, it does not fix, it does not remediate. Its role in the catalogue is another: it is the witness that a world can already sustain animals. If tardigrades can be active, the ecosystem already works.

Requirements to progress

TemperatureActive: temperate and humid. Dormant, in the dehydrated «tun» state (with 1–3 % of body water), it withstands from −272 °C to ~150 °C in brief laboratory exposures.
WaterTo be active: liquid water, without exception. Without it, it only waits in tun.
Light / O₂It produces nothing of its own: it needs food — algae, bacteria, other microanimals. It tolerates ~5,000–6,000 Gy of radiation depending on the species, about 1,000 times the lethal human dose, and pressures of up to ~6 times that of the bottom of the Mariana Trench. In the Foton-M3 mission (ESA, 2007), the groups protected from solar UV recovered after ~10–12 days in vacuum almost like the controls; direct solar UV caused severe mortality.
pHThat of a temperate and humid ecosystem already under way.
The honest trap: the phrase that governs this kit — survival ≠ colonization. The active tardigrade needs a prior ecosystem: it is an animal of an ecosystem, not a creator of ecosystems. It is not even a true extremophile: it is not adapted to exploit the extreme, and its probability of dying grows the longer the exposure lasts. It is a witness of a world that already sustains animals, not a seed.

Its first evolution

Its destiny on Earth

Its descendants on Earth:

The chain: first → second

First evolution

Shrinking: its evolution was miniaturization from larger lobopodian cousins, and perfecting the tun. The spectacular evolution — the arthropods — was done by its cousins, not by them.

Photograph of the fossil of Aysheaia pedunculata, Cambrian lobopodian, preserved in rock from Burgess Shale
«Its lobopodian cousin» — fossil of Aysheaia pedunculata, Cambrian lobopodian from Burgess Shale. Credit: Department of Paleobiology (Smithsonian), via Wikimedia Commons. License: CC0 — public domain. · 2025
Second evolution

It does not exist: ~500 Ma of stasis.

No figure: there is no step to photograph.

On Earth: when did it live, is it still alive?

They have fossils since the Cambrian, ~500 million years ago, and have survived the five mass extinctions being tardigrades. They are still alive today, in mosses, soils and waters all over the planet.

Source: TARDIS experiment (Foton-M3) and survival literature.

The pattern: almost no second evolution was done by the seed alone — either it was captured, or it joined another, or it lost something, or its family did it. Evolution, in these seven, is almost always an encounter.

THE KNOWN ONES AND THE ONE THAT IS MISSING — The seven on this page are the known ones: they have a date, a face and living descendants. LUCA is the one that is missing: the first known one that we do not yet know. The doubt remains open, on purpose.

What is known, and what remains open

Everything above is what is known on Earth: seven lineages with a date, a face and living descendants, and an inferred ancestor at the base. That is the firm ground of this page.

This piece walks on three floors: what we know — the dated terrestrial record —; what we propose it was — the theoretical reconstructions of the past: the traits of LUCA, the young worlds —; and what we might possibly find in our neighbourhood — Mars and Venus today, with the question still open.

Third floor — what we might possibly find in our neighbourhood

[THEORIZED · UNDER INVESTIGATION]

This is not ours: they are questions theorized by the scientific community, and each one carries its citation. The two works of this house go separately, below.

Mars

Martian life is not proven — neither present nor past. What there is: the seasonal methane, measured and disputed (its origin, geological or biological?, remains unsettled); the subsurface as a possible refuge where radiation does not reach; and the samples that the Perseverance rover has sealed in tubes, awaiting being brought to Earth.

State: under active investigation.

Citations: the seasonal methane was measured by the TLS instrument (tunable laser spectrometer) of the SAM laboratory aboard the Curiosity rover — Webster et al., 2018, Science —; the dispute arises from the upper limits of the ExoMars/TGO orbiter (ESA), which does not detect it — Korablev et al., 2019, Nature. The samples in tubes: Mars 2020 / Perseverance mission (NASA).

Venus

Nor is there proven life. What there is: the phosphine signal of 2020, which remains unsettled — neither confirmed nor fully refuted [IN DISPUTE]: later campaigns have again found candidate signals at low abundance, without independent confirmation; the cloud layer at 50–60 km as the least hostile theorized niche; and three missions in preparation that will measure the planet in the next decade: DAVINCI (NASA, target launch December 2030, with a descent probe), VERITAS (NASA, target November 2032) and EnVision (ESA, 2032).

State: under active investigation.

Citations: the phosphine signal — Greaves et al., 2020, Nature Astronomy —; the later dispute: Snellen et al., 2020, Astronomy & Astrophysics (reanalysis of the ALMA data) and Villanueva et al., 2021, Nature Astronomy, with later candidate signals from the JCMT-Venus programme, without consensus. The cloud niche and the missions: official fact sheets of the agencies — NASA (DAVINCI and VERITAS) and ESA (EnVision).

What is ours

In this same house, two sealed works work on those questions with their numbers and their method: Mars Core Reboot (the reboot of the core of Mars) and La Custodia de Venus (its thermal regulation). They are theorized studies of this house, not data: they go marked as such and are corrected with a date, like everything here.

What can be proven, and what is still under investigation. That is MathvsMyth.

This page remains open to the collaboration of whoever has a datum. Whoever contributes a datum, a correction or a measurement enters with their name and their date, as the house works.

Collaborate with an updated image

This page does not only await the missing image: it also receives the better or newer image of any of its beings, from whoever it comes — a person, a laboratory, a university, a school. Every image that enters, enters with the name of whoever brings it and with its date: that is the guarantee of the house. Joining this page is joining a mutual and social knowledge: what is corrected or improved here remains with its author and its day, for everyone.

Leave a datum, or join in collaborating

Without entering the beta

You can also leave a datum without entering the beta. You leave it right here, on this page, with your name or only with an alias — without email. And what you leave can be sealed right here, on the page, with its date: it remains fixed what was left and when. The alias is your key: with it you will be able to say, when you want to collaborate, that it was you.

Request your place in the beta

Entering is something else: it is for collaborating continuously. MathvsMyth is in beta, and the beta is temporary; there are no profiles yet. Whoever wants to collaborate continuously requests their place in the beta and says what they bring — as a person, laboratory, university or school. When the profiles open, whoever entered will already have their name — or their alias — and their date inside.

Request my place in the beta

Where each number comes from

Cards prepared by JCEA Labs from the cited literature. The main ones:

  • Water activity limit (aw ≈ 0.605): Stevenson et al., 2015, Environmental Microbiology.
  • Pyrolobus fumarii: Blöchl et al., 1997, Extremophiles; genome in Standards in Genomic Sciences (PMC).
  • Picrophilus oshimae: Schleper et al., 1996; genome in PNAS, Fütterer et al., 2004.
  • Deinococcus radiodurans: Murray, 1992, in The Prokaryotes; analysis in PNAS; Fredrickson et al., 2000 (PMC).
  • Great Oxidation and ceiling of photosynthesis (73 °C): American Society for Microbiology; Applied and Environmental Microbiology (ASM).
  • Fixation of N2: Bergey's Manual; biogeochemistry notes (Fiveable); AMBE 101 notes (eagri.org).
  • Methanogens: review of methanogenesis and of biological methanation (MDPI, Energies); García et al., 2000.
  • Lichens in space: ESA, BIOPAN/Foton-M2 experiment (2005); Brandt et al., 2015, International Journal of Astrobiology (EXPOSE-E/LIFE).
  • Tardigrades: literature gathered in Tardigrade (Wikipedia, with refs.); TARDIS experiment, Foton-M3 (ESA, 2007).
  • Evolutionary destinies: Taylor, Hass, Remy & Kerp, 1995, Nature 378:244 (Rhynie lichen); Lavin et al., 2005, and Sprent, 2008 (rhizobia–legume symbioses).
  • LUCA — reconstructed traits: Weiss et al., 2016, Nature Microbiology (~355 gene families; anaerobic, dependent on H2, fixation of CO2 via the Wood-Ljungdahl pathway).
  • LUCA — date and complexity: Moody et al., 2024, Nature Ecology & Evolution (~4,200 Ma, range 4,090–4,330 Ma; genome ≥2.5 Mb; early immune system).

What the cited literature leaves as «not verified», «with caution» or «under debate», this guide marks the same, next to the datum.

Author: Juan Carlos Euyoque Aguilera · JCEA Labs — November 4, 2026 · License CC BY 4.0: free use with attribution.

Origin

The First Signs of Life — a piece sealed with the Origin Method (hash e6b27b6841ee8ab9fafdd2afe2955887f008b9ffc9311bf537e457950f04bb1c, CC BY 4.0). OpenTimestamps stamp: registered with 4 calendars; Bitcoin anchor confirmed in blocks 974625, 974617 and 974615. The sealed content is the content of this page, without the site navigation chrome.